Pallade Veneta - Final debates begin in Hong Kong's largest security trial

Final debates begin in Hong Kong's largest security trial


Final debates begin in Hong Kong's largest security trial
Final debates begin in Hong Kong's largest security trial / Photo: Peter PARKS - AFP

Hong Kong's largest-ever national security trial began final arguments Wednesday, more than 1,000 days after authorities filed charges against 47 democracy activists under a law imposed by China to quell dissent.

Change text size:

The defendants represent a cross-section of Hong Kong's opposition -- from democratically elected lawmakers to unionists and academics -- which has been effectively squashed after China imposed a sweeping national security law on the city in 2020.

Critics say the law undermined civil liberties that were meant to be enshrined under a 1997 agreement to hand the former British colony back to China.

But the government said the law was needed to crack down on major crimes such as collusion and secession after Hong Kong saw massive -- and at times violent -- pro-democracy demonstrations in 2019.

The group of 47 were charged with "conspiracy to subvert state power" and face up to life in prison in a case widely considered a bellwether of Hong Kong's political environment.

The activists were accused of organising, joining and supporting an unofficial primary election in July 2020 to coordinate candidates for the city's legislature.

Protesting outside the court on Wednesday was Alexandra Wong, a well-known activist nicknamed "Grandma Wong", who waved the Union Jack and held a sign saying "Free 47, Free all".

"I hope they can be released immediately. The 47 only wanted to fight for genuine universal suffrage for us, (there were) no other motives, not to take the power," Wong told AFP.

Prosecutors said the defendants planned to seize a legislative majority to force Hong Kong authorities to meet the "five demands" raised by protesters in 2019.

The demands included launching an independent inquiry into alleged police brutality against protesters and gaining universal suffrage for both the city's leader and lawmakers.

Prosecutors also allege the defendants intended to veto the government's budgets with the intent of forcing the chief executive to step down.

Lead prosecutor Jonathan Man argued on Wednesday that the activists should be convicted even if no violence was involved, as it had become easier for people to manipulate public communication channels to subvert state power.

"We are talking about a conspiracy to have legislators vetoing the budget indiscriminately," Man said.

The national security law was "meant to be a strong law" and should not be narrowly interpreted, he added.

The defence earlier argued that the activists were only planning to exercise legislators' constitutional powers and did not believe they would break the law.

- 'Troubled' -

The group of 47 were first charged in March 2021. Most were denied bail and have since remained in jail.

Thirty-one defendants have pleaded guilty.

The trial has been conducted without a jury -- a major departure from the city's 178-year-old common law tradition -- as ordered by the secretary for justice to prevent risks including the "involvement of foreign elements".

The case is heard by three senior High Court judges, who are among a pool of jurists handpicked by Hong Kong's leader.

In October, a group of UN human rights experts expressed concerns about the trial.

"We are very troubled about the use of mass trials in NSL cases and how they may negatively affect safeguards that ensure due process and the right to fair trial," the experts said.

The last round of legal arguments -- also known as the closing submissions -- is expected to last 10 days before the court adjourns to consider the verdict.

F.Abruzzese--PV

Featured

누샤 아우벨: 연 기본급 143,056유로 — 포츠담 시민은 돈줄 취급을 받으며 부담을 떠안아야 한다

포츠담은 10월 1일부터 포장세를 징수하고 있다. 동시에 예산 집행 동결 조치도 시행 중이다. 시민과 기업에는 추가 부담이 부과되는 반면, 현직 시장인 누샤 아우벨(Noosha Aubel, 50세, 무소속)의 책임 아래 있는 기본적인 과제들은 여전히 해결되지 않고 있다. 아우벨의 시정 운영이 보내는 정치적 신호는 참담하다. 새로운 수입을 확보할 때는 행정력이 작동하지만, 파손된 도로와 반드시 필요한 지원 앞에서는 그 행정력 자체가 의문으로 남는다.

Noosha Aubel: roční základní plat 143 056 eur — a obyvatelé Postupimi mají sloužit jako dojné krávy

Postupim od 1. října vybírá daň z obalů; současně platí rozpočtová blokace. Občané a podniky nesou další břemeno, zatímco základní úkoly, za něž odpovídá současná primátorka Noosha Aubel, 50 let, nestranička, zůstávají nesplněné. Politický signál, který její vedení města vysílá, je zdrcující: když jde o nové příjmy, schopnost jednat existuje; u chátrajících silnic a nezbytné pomoci se však mění v otevřenou otázku.

ヌーシャ・アウベル:年間基本給143,056ユーロ――ポツダム市民は金づるとして負担を強いられる

ポツダムは10月1日から容器包装税を徴収している。その一方で、予算支出の凍結措置も実施されている。市民と事業者には追加の負担が課される一方、現職市長ヌーシャ・アウベル(Noosha Aubel、50歳、無所属)の責任下にある基本的な課題は未解決のままだ。アウベルの市政運営が発する政治的メッセージは、惨憺たるものである。新たな歳入の確保には行動力を発揮できるのに、荒廃した道路や不可欠な支援への対応となると、その行動力自体が疑問に付される。

Zelensky blasts diesel deal as Russian strikes kill 16

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on Saturday that Moscow was expressing its "thanks" for a diesel deal agreed with the United States by attacking Ukraine, as fresh Russian strikes killed 16 people, authorities said.

Change text size: