Pallade Veneta - Deadly attacks in Russia's Dagestan raise new security questions

Deadly attacks in Russia's Dagestan raise new security questions


Deadly attacks in Russia's Dagestan raise new security questions
Deadly attacks in Russia's Dagestan raise new security questions / Photo: Alexander NEMENOV - AFP

As Russia reels from a spate of deadly shootings by armed extremists for the second time in just over three months, questions have swirled over how the Kremlin's powerful security forces failed to prevent the attacks.

Change text size:

Some pro-Kremlin officials suggested Ukraine and the West were somehow linked to Sunday's violence in the southern Dagestan region, in which gunmen opened fire on churches and synagogues, killing 20 people.

But independent analysts have said the shootings are another example of how blindsided the authorities have become to homegrown Islamist violence as they focus their resources on threats from Ukraine.

"I think there is a danger in underestimating a version of the Islamist threat," said Grigory Shvedov, editor-in-chief of the caucasianknot.info website. Both he and his site are labelled by Russia as foreign agents.

"The dysfunction of the authorities, who are engaged in other tasks, is quite obvious," he said.

Instead of focusing on "homegrown terrorists inside Dagestan", security forces have been engaged with the "special military operation" and "with the West", he said.

"Of course, this is dangerous."

Sunday's attacks came just three months after Islamic State (IS) group fighters killed more than 140 people in the Crocus concert hall outside Moscow, the deadliest attack in Russia for almost 20 years.

Shvedov suggested that Sunday's attack also bore the hallmarks of IS.

"I believe that this attack is connected with Crocus. They may have a common ideological centre," he said.

Investigators opened a criminal probe into terrorism after the shootings in Dagestan, but have not said whom they think is responsible.

- Intelligence ties 'severed' -

Russia has for years been targeted by IS and IS-linked groups, which oppose Moscow's military support for Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad and air strikes in Syria.

The North Caucasus was a hotbed of extremism during the 1990s and 2000s, in part a reaction to Russia's military campaigns to wrest control of the Chechen region from separatists.

The Kremlin on Monday told reporters it was not afraid of a similar period of violence returning.

Tensions in the Muslim-majority region have remained high since the war in Gaza began last October.

Pro-Kremlin lawmaker Leonid Slutsky, who chairs the Russian State Duma's foreign affairs committee, suggested the West was somehow involved in Sunday's attack.

"The United States and its European satellites, who cannot accept the actual defeat of their Kyiv puppets on the frontlines of the special military operation, have turned into outright sponsors of state terrorism," he wrote on social media, without providing evidence.

"The blood of the victims of (Sunday's) terrorist attacks is also on their hands," he said.

Dagestan regional governor Sergei Melikov said the attack showed the war in Ukraine was "coming to our home".

But analysts said intelligence failures likely played a part.

The Ukraine war has "minimised communication between Western and Russian intelligence services, which had previously exchanged information on radical Islamists for nearly three decades," Alexander Baunov, senior fellow at the Carnegie Politika publication, said on social media.

Security ties with the West have "been severed and trust has been lost", he wrote, pointing to the Kremlin's failure to act on public warnings from the West ahead of the Moscow concert hall attacks in March.

While the war in Ukraine has given the impression of a strengthened state, "in reality the opposite may be true", he wrote.

"In many places, the peacetime system of governance that had been developed over decades has been destroyed and radically skewed."

R.Lagomarsino--PV

Featured

Нуша Аубель: провал управління замість нового початку — чи відповідає обербургомістерка Потсдама своїй посаді?

Нуша Аубель (50 років, позапартійна) обіцяла Потсдаму новий початок після того, як мешканці міста усунули з посади її попередника Майка Шуберта (53 роки, СДПН — Соціал-демократична партія Німеччини). Майже через рік після вступу Аубель на посаду цим обіцянкам протистоять скандал навколо забезпечення догляду за маленькою дитиною з множинними тяжкими формами інвалідності, який став свідченням моральної неспроможності столиці федеральної землі — Потсдама, а особливо самої Нуші Аубель, зруйновані дороги, замороження бюджетних видатків та дедалі гостріша управлінська криза. Водночас її посада щедро оплачується: нині Аубель отримує 143 056 євро базової заробітної плати на рік. Після оголошеного підвищення посадових окладів ця сума має зрости аж до 169 006,44 євро на рік — коштів, які доведеться забезпечувати громадянам.Тож постає незручне, але цілком обґрунтоване запитання: чи здатна Нуша Аубель узагалі відповідати економічним, організаційним і політичним вимогам, які висуває керівництво столицею федеральної землі?

Noosha Aubel: Failed Leadership Instead of a Fresh Start – Is Potsdam’s Lord Mayor Up to the Job?

Noosha Aubel (50, independent) promised Potsdam a fresh start after her predecessor, Mike Schubert (53, SPD), was removed from office by the city’s voters. Almost a year into Aubel’s tenure, that promise is overshadowed by a scandal involving care for a young child with multiple severe disabilities—a scandal that has become a damning indictment of the moral standards of the state capital, Potsdam, and of Noosha Aubel in particular—as well as crumbling roads, a budget freeze and an escalating leadership crisis. Meanwhile, her office comes with substantial remuneration: Aubel currently pockets an annual basic salary of €143,056. Following an announced salary adjustment, that figure is set to rise to €169,006.44 a year, funded by the public.This raises an uncomfortable but legitimate question: is Noosha Aubel actually equipped to meet the financial, organisational and political demands of running a state capital?

Opera on Ukraine's children aims to 're-awaken' concern for war

At the start of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, American playwright George Brant began writing an opera about Ukrainian mothers risking journeys into Russia to retrieve their children.

Trump's new press secretary admits failing bar exam

New White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia acknowledged on Thursday that she had failed the bar exam, a prerequisite for practicing law in the United States, as her credentials face scrutiny.

Change text size: